We'll go into a more detailed analysis as we approach February, but for now here's a quick rundown of this morning's nominations:
Best Picture
:: Atonement
:: Juno
:: Michael Clayton
:: No Country for Old Men
:: There Will Be Blood
Thumbs up for...: Atonement. No Country for Old Men and There Will Be Blood were expected nominees. However, after getting bitch slapped by the Guilds all season long, Atonement was poised to become this year's "Dreamgirls." Now it can call itself one of the year's 5 best.
Thumbs down for...: Juno and Michael Clayton, which were both "good but not Oscar-worthy" films in my book.
Best Director
:: Julian Schnabel, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
:: Jason Reitman, Juno
:: Tony Gilroy, Michael Clayton
:: Ethan and Joel Coen, No Country for Old Men
:: Paul Thomas Anderson, There Will Be Blood
Thumbs up for...: Paul Thomas Anderson, who finally got his due.
Thumbs down for...: Tony Gilroy. "Michael Clayton" was an auspicious debut but it paled in comparison to more deserving contenders like Joe Wright and "Bourne"-alum Paul Greengrass.
Best Actor
:: George Clooney, Michael Clayton
:: Daniel Day-Lewis, There Will Be Blood
:: Johnny Depp, Sweeney Todd
:: Tommy Lee Jones, In the Valley of Elah
:: Viggo Mortensen, Eastern Promises
Thumbs up for...: Viggo Mortensen. We knew it would finally happen, but it's still nice to see nonetheless.
Thumbs down for...: Tommy Lee Jones. Jones gave a fine performance in "In the Valley of Elah," but his supporting turn in "No Country for Old Men" was far more deserving.
Best Actress
:: Cate Blanchett, The Golden Age
:: Julie Christie, Away From Her
:: Marion Cotillard, La Vie En Rose
:: Laura Linney, The Savages
:: Ellen Page, Juno
Thumbs up for...: Laura Linney. She just missed my Best Actress ballot, but kudos to voters for remembering her wonderfully subtle turn in "The Savages."
Thumbs down for...: Cate Blanchett. One nomination is fine, but this is pushing it.
Best Supporting Actor
:: Casey Affleck, The Assassination of Jesse James
:: Javier Bardem, No Country for Old Men
:: Philip Seymour Hoffman, Charlie Wilson's War
:: Hal Holbrook, Into the Wild
:: Tom Wilkinson, Michael Clayton
Thumbs up for...: Casey Affleck, who held on strong for the entire season.
Thumbs down for...: Philip Seymour Hoffman. Like most of "Charlie Wilson's War," Hoffman's servicable performance barely registered.
Best Supporting Actress
:: Cate Blanchett, I'm Not There
:: Ruby Dee, American Gangster
:: Saoirse Ronan, Atonement
:: Amy Ryan, Gone Baby Gone
:: Tilda Swinton, Michael Clayton
Thumbs up for...: Saoirse Ronan, arguably the best of the 3 Brionys.
Thumbs down for...: Ruby Dee, who was probably nominated more for her career than her underwhelming performance in "American Gangster."
Best Original Screenplay
:: Juno
:: Lars and the Real Girl
:: Michael Clayton
:: Ratatouille
:: The Savages
Thumbs up for...: Ratatouille & The Savages, two extremely well-written films.
Thumbs down for...: Michael Clayton, which had about one too many structural problems (meandering subplots, for starters).
Best Adapted Screenplay
:: Atonement
:: Away From Her
:: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
:: No Country for Old Men
:: There Will Be Blood
Thumbs up for...: Away From Her, a nice surprise nominee.
Thumbs down for...: none. This is a relatively strong category.
I have to say I'm pretty pleased with this morning's nominations. Yes, there were misses in every category, but overall I would say these are A LOT better than last year's.
What about you guys? How would you rate the 2007 Oscar nominations?